The impact of mass deworming programmes on schooling and economic development: an appraisal of long-term studies

Jullien, Sophie, Sinclair, David and Garner, Paul ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0607-6941 (2017) 'The impact of mass deworming programmes on schooling and economic development: an appraisal of long-term studies'. International Journal of Epidemiology, Vol 45, Issue 6, pp. 2140-2153.

	Text (This is a pre-copyedited, author-produced PDF of an article accepted for publication in Int J Epidemiology following peer review.) IJE WORMS Long term effects text 5 Sept (new reference added).docx - Accepted Version Download (65kB)
	Text IJE worms main tables 4 SEPT.docx - Supplemental Material Download (91kB)
	Text IJE WORMS Supplementary material 4 Sept.docx - Supplemental Material Download (32kB)
Preview	Text impact of mass deworming_Published_6_2_17.pdf - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial. Download (398kB) | Preview

Abstract

Background
Documents from advocacy and fund-raising organizations for child mass deworming programmes in low and middle-income countries cite unpublished economic studies claiming long-term effects on health, schooling and economic development.

Methods
To summarise and appraise these studies, we searched for and included all long-term follow-up studies, based on cluster-randomized trials included in a 2015 Cochrane review on deworming. We used Cochrane methods to assess risk of bias, and appraised the credibility of the main findings. Where necessary we contacted study authors for clarifications.

Results
We identified three studies (Baird 2016, Ozier 2016, and Croke 2014), evaluating effects more than nine years after cluster-randomized trials in Kenya and Uganda. Baird and Croke evaluate short additional exposures to deworming programmes in settings where all children were dewormed multiple times. Ozier evaluates potential spin-off effects to infants living in areas with school-based deworming. None of the studies used pre-planned protocols, or blinded the analysis to treatment allocation.
Baird 2016 has been presented on-line in six iterations. It is at high risk of reporting bias and selective reporting, and there are substantive changes between versions. The main cited effects on secondary school attendance and job sector allocation are from post-hoc sub-group analyses, which the study was not powered to assess. The study finds no evidence of effect on nutritional status, cognitive tests, or school grades achieved, but these are not reported in the abstracts.
Ozier 2016 has been presented on-line in four iterations, without substantive differences between versions. Higher cognitive test scores were associated with deworming but were only beyond the play of chance with inclusion of the non-randomised data. The size of the stated effect seems inconsistent with the short and indirect nature of the exposure to deworming, and a causal pathway for this effect is unclear.
Croke 2014 utilizes a data set unrelated to the base trial to report improvements in English and maths test scores. The analysis is at high risk of attrition bias, due to loss of clusters, and is substantially underpowered to assess these effects.

Conclusion
In the context of reliable epidemiological methods, all three studies are at risk of substantial methodological bias. They therefore help in generating hypothesis, but should not be considered reliable evidence of effects.

Item Type:	Article
Subjects:	QX Parasitology > Helminths. Annelida > QX 200 Helminths QX Parasitology > QX 4 General works WA Public Health > WA 30 Socioeconomic factors in public health (General) WA Public Health > Health Problems of Special Population Groups > WA 395 Health in developing countries WS Pediatrics > Diseases of Children and Adolescents > General Diseases > WS 200 General works
Faculty: Department:	Clinical Sciences & International Health > Clinical Sciences Department
Digital Object Identifer (DOI):	https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/dyw283
Depositing User:	Christianne Esparza
Date Deposited:	09 Sep 2016 09:37
Last Modified:	06 Sep 2019 10:15
URI:	https://archive.lstmed.ac.uk/id/eprint/6105

Statistics

View details

Actions (login required)

Edit Item